Marcellus Outreach Butler
Connect with us
  • Home
  • Get Involved
    • Join Our Mailing List
    • Write Letters to the Editor
    • Contact Elected Officials
    • Track Permit Activity
    • Local Groups
    • PAF Farmers Letter to Governor Wolf
  • Concerned?
    • Krendale Neighbors
    • Emergency Contacts for Gasfield Residents
    • File a Complaint or Report an Incident
    • Property Values
    • Before You Sign a Lease
    • Water Testing
  • Fracking Impacts
    • Toxic Chemicals
    • Human Health Impacts
    • First Person Experiences
    • The Impact of Act 13 (HB 1950)
  • Resources
    • MOB Generated Info >
      • Butler Water Supply at Risk
      • Bat Signal
      • Spill Baby Spill
    • Books >
      • Fracking
      • Climate Change
    • Films
    • Websites
  • Membership & Giving
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Blog

Proof is in the Eye of the Beholder

12/17/2011

 
_After more than two years of study, the EPA released a draft report indicating that groundwater contamination may have resulted from hydraulic fracturing in Pavillion, Wyoming.  The report emphasizes that this is just the first step in the analysis and that the data is open for a 45-day public comment period and a 30-day peer review.  Residents of Pavilion have long complained of health issues related to a natural gas field owned by Encana.   Not surprisingly, Encana, the Petroleum Association of Wyoming (PAW), and politicians quickly took aim at the report, finding fault wherever they could.  But do they hold themselves to the same standards?

Encana questioned EPA’s methodology stating that results were likely caused by “problems associated with...drilling and sampling.”  PAW called the results “unsubstantiated” and “irresponsible.”  Senator James Inhofe (R) called them “premature” and raised questions “regarding EPA’s data and methodologies.”  They have all demanded more independent testing and peer review.

This national story quickly brought to mind the cases of contaminated water in Connoquennesing Township that implicate REX Energy.  On December 3, 2011 the Butler Eagle published a story on the front page that lead with “Well water is fine for human use.”  It is based on a report prepared by AMEC from Sewickley, PA; an engineering consultancy firm contracted by Rex.

Although the AMEC report was dated October 10, 2011, Rex Energy did not release their findings to the homeowners until December 2, 2011 and only after attending a meeting to discuss the report with the Butler Eagle.  The homeowners were not invited to this or any other meeting to discuss the report.  They received a packet via UPS.  This begs the questions, who was the report produced for?  The homeowners or the press?

The cited report contains several serious flaws.  The report clearly states that the report was solely based “on data provided to AMEC by Rex Energy” and that “AMEC inferred likely groundwater flow.”  No one from AMEC ever contacted the landowners to verify well depth, date of complaints, current conditions, or to request other tests done by the homeowners or the DEP.  AMEC never set foot on the properties to take a water sample nor did they oversee the sampling or the testing.  Did AMEC even verify the calibration of the test equipment?  How could they?  The testing was done by Environmental Service Laboratories Inc. (ESL) based out of Indiana, Pa.  The samples were taken and the tests completed before August of 2011 often without oversight by DEP (against the DEP agents’ wishes).  The results were then sent to Rex.  According to their website “ESL is a proud member of the Marcellus Shale Coalition.”  Is this what an “independent study” looks like?  Was this report vetted by peer review and public comment? Would this report stand up in court?

Nonetheless, the result of this report and others like it is that six families in Connoquennesing Township will stop receiving potable water after the New Year, including a three-year-old girl, a newborn and, a pregnant mother and no one has stepped up to question the  validity of the report.  Where are our local officials?  The press?  The DEP?

Although REX Energy has operations in Wyoming, is unknown whether or not REX Energy is a member of PAW as PAW refuses to disclose their membership (in fact, when asked for a list of their members the PAW representative on the other end of the phone’s first response was to laugh and say, “You don’t have enough money to know that.”)

How is it that the natural gas industry demands high standards of proof and transparency from others yet hides behind secrecy, stretched-truths, and assumptions when the shoe is on the other foot?

Jason Bell

Kim McEvoy
12/21/2011 10:20:29 pm

I am such a neverous wreck, Im still waiting to hear from the water company to see how much its going to cost to keep my water bufflo. the gentalman who owns the water bufflo company is working to make the water affordable for me and others who want to keep the water. Also we are getting 2 or more gas wells in our neighborhood around January/ Febuary. The compressers for our new compresser station arrived the other day Im sure that will be up and running soon. When will this ever stop?

contact lenses in Collinsville link
7/19/2012 09:57:34 pm

Interesting post and thanks for sharing. Some things in here I have not thought about before. Thanks for making such a cool post which is really very well written. Will be referring a lot of friends about this. Keep blogging.

Paula S.
12/31/2011 12:57:35 am

Kim, I never thought that this could happen in our little rural community and now i see it all around us. You are very courageous for speaking out when so many have been silenced. Perhaps the M.O.B. can set up a fund to assist those being impacted so directly?

Dave P.
3/1/2012 08:15:48 pm

Environmental Service Laboratories, Inc. has a larger conflict of interest than being a member or the Marcellus Coalition. Landowners should hire an attorney before allowing them onto the premises.

Did deep Mr. Bell and your research will pay off!

You will find that the owner owns an interest in the gas company often contracted to drill the vertical bores for the wells and in some cases owns the rights and/or surface. She is sampling the water, the water which is of financial and political benefit to come back clean.

There is nothing environmental about this company. One of their employees told me years ago that they also have a surveying company. So get this straight...They drill the well, in some cases own it or an interest in it, own some land by it, survey the land, they are supposed to be trusted to test the water. AND WE ARE SUPPOSED TO TRUST THE RESULTS. Independent...HA!

Conflict of Interest. Period.

laser eye surgery link
4/17/2012 09:09:10 pm

This is really great piece of work.I have read the article and got the feelings that it is incredibly well written and easy to understand.

King Neece link
7/30/2012 06:28:40 am

Easily remove radiation from any water source

Our University of Alabama patented solar desalination product uses no electricity, has no filters to replace, can be taken anywhere and extracts pure water from any contaminated water source. It removes radiation, fluoride, salt, pesticides, bacteria, dirt and other contaminants from any water. It aids people to be prepared for disasters. Made tough in the U.S.A.

Please visit us:
http://freshwater.ecogreenenergies.com

King link
4/4/2013 02:35:15 am

Eco friendly product reviews featuring clean water, energy savings, prepper sites and sustainable energy products.

http://values.cc


This is also our new website for our earlier comment about the University of Alabama solar desalination products.


Comments are closed.

    Authors

    Blog posts written by members of Marcellus Outreach Butler.

    Archives

    April 2017
    February 2017
    September 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    May 2011

    Categories

    All
    13
    Act
    Act 13
    Action
    Activism
    Air Pollution
    Alternative Energy
    Aquifer
    Banking
    Birth Defects
    Butler Township
    Cement Casings
    Chainsaw
    Challenge
    Chemicals Used
    Children
    Children's Health
    Civil Disobedience
    Civil Rights
    Clean Air Act
    Clean Air Council
    Clean Energy
    Clean Water Act
    Climate Change
    Commomwealth Court
    Concerned Health Professionals Of New York
    Constitution
    Constitution Pipeline
    Contaminated Water
    County Commissioners
    Court
    Cutting Trees For Pipelines
    Deception
    Definition
    Delaware Riverkeeper Network
    Dep
    Doctor
    Drilling Ban
    EMA
    Emergency Management
    Eminent Domain
    Energy Revolution
    Environment
    Environmental Impacts
    Environmental Regulations
    Evacuation
    Farmers
    Farmers Against Fracking
    Farms
    Farm Show
    Flaring
    Flowback
    Forest Stewardship Program
    Fracking
    Franklin Township
    Gas Industry Lies
    Gas Lease
    Gerhart
    Geyer Wellpad
    Governor Tom Wolf
    Grandparents
    Groundwater Contamination Cases
    Halliburtan Loophole
    Health
    Health & Safety
    Health Study
    Holleran
    Holleran-Zeffer
    Hormone-disrupting
    House Bill 1950
    Impact Fees
    Jackson Township
    James Cromwell
    Lake Arthur
    Law
    Law Suit
    Lawyer
    Legislation
    Long Term Effects
    Long-term Effects
    Maggie Henry
    Maple Farm
    Maple Sugaring
    Margaret Flower
    Mars Parent Group
    Mars School Board
    Mars Schools
    M.D.
    Middlesex Planning Commission
    Middlesex Township
    Moraine State Park
    Mortgage
    Municipal Water
    Nonviolent Direct Action
    Pa Constitution
    Pediatrician
    Pennsylvanians Against Fracking
    Pipeline
    Property Value
    Proposed Processing Plant
    Protest
    Radiation
    Rally
    Real Estate
    Renewable Energy
    Rep. Brian Ellis
    Residential Drilling
    Resist
    Rex Energy
    Rights Of The People
    Sacrifice Zone
    Safety
    School
    Seneca Valley School
    Sen. White
    Solar
    Stephen Cleghorn
    Stop The Frack Attack
    Supreme Court Ruling
    Sustainable
    Tar Sands
    Tourism
    Unconventional
    Vehicle Acidents
    Violations
    Water
    Water Testing
    Well Casings
    Well Integrity
    Wendell Berry
    Woodlands
    XTO
    Zoning

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.